Cost per order is your total monthly fulfillment spend divided by the orders you shipped that month, counting pick and pack, packaging, storage, receiving, returns, account fees and postage. Use it to compare an itemized 3PL quote with a bundled one, or a 3PL with shipping in-house.
How to calculate it
Add every line for one month and divide by orders shipped:
Cost per order = (pick and pack + packaging + storage + receiving + returns + account fees + postage) ÷ orders shipped
Work it out two ways. Fees before postage tell you how the 3PL prices its own work. The all-in figure, postage included, is what each order costs your business. Run every quote through the same month of your own orders, because a rate card prices activities and your order mix decides the bill.
Worked example at 5,000 orders a month
Example rates, not Orderfy's. The brand ships 1.5 items per order, holds 40 pallets, receives 20 pallets a month and has a 4% return rate.
| Line | Basis | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Pick and pack | 5,000 orders at $2.75 | $13,750 |
| Additional items | 2,500 items at $0.45 | $1,125 |
| Packaging | 5,000 orders at $0.45 | $2,250 |
| Storage | 40 pallets at $20 | $800 |
| Receiving | 20 pallets at $9 | $180 |
| Returns | 200 returns at $3.00 | $600 |
| Fees before postage | Sum of the lines above | $18,705 ($3.74 per order) |
| Postage | 5,000 parcels at $7.00 average | $35,000 |
| All-in | Fees plus postage | $53,705 ($10.74 per order) |
Postage is about 65% of the all-in figure. At this volume, 30 cents off the average label saves $1,500 a month, more than 20 cents off the pick fee at $1,000.
What moves it
Your order profile moves cost per order more than small changes to the rates:
- Items per order: each extra item adds an additional pick fee.
- Return rate: every return adds a processing fee.
- Stock on hand: slow SKUs keep paying storage.
- Charges outside the quote: hourly receiving, special projects and carrier adjustments show up as accessorial charges.
To compare a 3PL with shipping yourself, put labor, rent, equipment, software, packaging, errors and your own management time into the same formula. Our in-house vs 3PL comparison builds both sides at 5,000 and 10,000 orders a month.
How we bill it at Orderfy
Every charge is itemized before you sign, and each one shows in Orderfy WMS, the inventory software we built in-house, on the order it belongs to. Billing is weekly with autopay, so you can check your cost per order each week against the orders behind it.
Frequently asked questions
It should when you compare total cost. Track it before postage to compare 3PL fees and all-in to compare what each order costs you, since postage was about 65% of the all-in figure in the example above.
There's no single benchmark, because items per order, package weight and destination all move it. For fees alone, The Fulfillment Advisor's 2026 survey of 500 providers averaged $3.21 to pick and pack a one-item direct-to-consumer order, before packaging, storage, receiving, returns and postage.
Add one month of loaded labor, rent, equipment, software, packaging, error costs and management time, then add postage and divide by orders shipped. Compare the result with a 3PL quote run on the same month of orders.
Get a quote from Orderfy
Send your monthly order volume and what you ship, and we'll build an itemized quote.