Fulfyld charges one flat per-order rate for D2C brands at 500 to 5,000+ orders a month, ships everything from one inventory pool in the Huntsville, Alabama metro and publishes no dollar rates. Orderfy ships from one warehouse in the center of the US, quotes pick and pack from $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders, and shows each charge on the order it belongs to in Orderfy WMS.

We’re Orderfy, so we’re not neutral. The Fulfyld details below come from Fulfyld’s own website, checked on November 17, 2026, with links at the end. Prices and policies change, so confirm anything important with Fulfyld directly.

Quick Answer

Choose Fulfyld if:

  • You want one flat per-order rate that covers pick, pack, receiving, integrations and the account manager
  • You want an SLA backed by financial credits that appear automatically on the next invoice
  • Most of your customers are in the Southeast, close to its Huntsville, Alabama warehouse
  • You want a dedicated account manager and phone and chat support

Choose Orderfy if you’re a high-volume Shopify brand and want:

  • Orderfy WMS, proprietary software built in-house and included for every client
  • Every charge itemized and shown on the order it belongs to
  • Photos of every outgoing shipment, with the carrier handoff time on the order
  • Inventory received within 24 hours of delivery
  • One warehouse in the center of the US, with direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the warehouse team

Orderfy vs Fulfyld at a glance

OrderfyFulfyld
LocationOne warehouse in the center of the US (Dallas–Fort Worth)One inventory pool in the Huntsville, Alabama metro; headquarters in Madison, AL
Who it’s forShopify brands shipping 1,000 to 10,000 orders a month, plus Amazon sellers. No volume minimumD2C brands, 500 to 5,000+ orders a month, in beauty and cosmetics, supplements, apparel, food and beverage, health and wellness and subscription boxes
PricingItemized quote. Pick and pack from $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item ordersOne flat, all-inclusive rate per order; dollar rates not published; quotes within one business day
Other feesMonthly account fee for smaller accounts, waived at high volume and listed on your quote“No hidden fees, setup surprises, or long-term contracts”
BillingWeekly, with autopay. Each charge shows in Orderfy WMS on the order it belongs toNot published; SLA credits appear on the next invoice
Warehouse softwareOrderfy WMS, proprietary and built in-house, includedNot named on its site; it describes “our 3PL fulfillment software” and an ecommerce dashboard
Shopify connectionNative Shopify app. Orders reach us within minutes, stock syncs in real time and tracking posts when the label is createdOne of 8+ cart integrations, including Shopify, Shopify Plus, WooCommerce, Amazon, Walmart, BigCommerce, eBay and Magento
Same-day shippingSame-day shippingSame-day pick and pack for orders placed by 1PM local warehouse time
ReceivingWithin 24 hours of delivery, counted against your packing list and photographedDock-to-stock in two business days
Accuracy99.9%, tracked in Orderfy WMS. A wrong or incomplete order is reshipped free and its fulfillment fee credited99.9% pick accuracy; formal SLA backed by financial credits on the next invoice; terms not published
SupportDirect communication channels for 24/7 access to the warehouse teamA dedicated account manager for every brand; phone and chat
Shipment photosEvery outgoing shipment, on the order with the carrier handoff timeNot published
Other servicesFBM fulfillment, plus FBA prep through Orderfy PrepFBA prep, kitting, returns, B2B and retail, and Kickstarter fulfillment; serves the USA and Canada
OnboardingWe plan the move with you. Inventory is received within 24 hours of delivery, counted and photographedMost brands live within two weeks; the account manager handles migrations

Where Fulfyld is stronger

  • One simple flat rate. Fulfyld folds pick, pack, same-day shipping, receiving, dock-to-stock, integrations and the account manager into one per-order rate. If you want to compare one number against your current bill and don’t want to read a rate card, that’s easy to do. Itemized pricing is more detail, and some teams don’t want it.
  • An SLA with automatic credits. Fulfyld says it signs a formal SLA backed by financial credits, and that the credits appear on the next invoice without you filing a claim. A credit that arrives on its own is useful. The terms aren’t published, so read the document before you rely on it.
  • Closer to the Southeast. Its warehouse is in the Huntsville, Alabama metro, and its locations page says ground transit reaches most of the US in 1 to 3 days. If most of your customers are in Alabama, Georgia, Tennessee and the states around them, Huntsville sits closer to them than Dallas–Fort Worth does. Our look at when a regional 3PL beats a central warehouse covers how to test that with your own orders.
  • A named account manager for every brand. Fulfyld sets its dedicated account manager against ticket queues, and it offers phone and chat. Its about page shows 4.9/5 from 114+ growing D2C brands. That’s Fulfyld’s own figure and we haven’t verified it.
  • Specific vertical experience. Its pages name beauty and cosmetics, supplements, apparel, food and beverage, health and wellness and subscription boxes, and Kickstarter fulfillment. If you’re in one of those categories, ask which clients it already ships for.

Where Orderfy is stronger

  • Software your 3PL built. Orderfy WMS is proprietary, built in-house and included for every client. Orders, stock, charges and photos sit in one system run by the team that runs the warehouse. Fulfyld describes a dashboard and “automated API integration” but doesn’t say which warehouse software sits behind it. When a Shopify brand kept some stock in its own building, we added a setting so Orderfy WMS takes only the orders Shopify routes to us, and that kind of change is easier when the software is ours.
  • Every charge on its order. We itemize charges before you sign and show each one in Orderfy WMS on the order it belongs to. You see what each order cost rather than one blended rate. We bill weekly with autopay. Fulfyld’s billing schedule isn’t published.
  • A photo of every shipment. Staff photograph every outgoing shipment, and the order page shows the carrier handoff time with the photos. Deliveries are counted against your packing list and photographed on arrival. Fulfyld doesn’t publish shipment photos.
  • Receiving within 24 hours. We receive inventory within 24 hours of delivery, and stock levels update in Shopify once it’s counted in. Fulfyld’s dock-to-stock is two business days. For a restock before a launch, each day in receiving is a day without stock to sell.
  • A published accuracy remedy. A wrong or incomplete order is reshipped free and its fulfillment fee credited, and the 99.9% rate is tracked in Orderfy WMS. Both companies publish 99.9%; the difference is that our remedy is stated on the page, while Fulfyld’s SLA terms aren’t posted.
  • The warehouse team, any hour. Every client gets direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the people handling their inventory, and any order on hold shows the reason in Orderfy WMS. You’re welcome to tour the warehouse.
  • Shopify and Amazon from one team. Orderfy handles Shopify and FBM orders and runs Orderfy Prep for FBA prep, tracked in Orderfy WMS.

Pricing

Fulfyld prices on one flat per-order rate and says it’s all-inclusive: pick, pack, same-day shipping, receiving and dock-to-stock, integrations and the account manager. It states there are no hidden fees, setup surprises or long-term contracts, and it promises a quote within one business day. It publishes no dollar rates, so you can’t compare it to anything until you have that quote.

The flat rate makes budgeting simple, and it also hides how the cost splits across work. If you ship single-item orders, a blended per-order rate may be fine. If you ship multi-item orders, bundles or heavy inbound volume, you want to know whether the rate moves with item count and what receiving costs in a month when you send a lot of stock. Ask Fulfyld three questions: what the rate covers for a three-item order, what it covers when you send two pallets in one week, and whether postage is billed separately.

Orderfy quotes from your numbers: orders per month, items per order, storage, receiving and packaging. Pick and pack starts as low as $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders. Smaller accounts pay a monthly account fee that depends on volume and services, and high-volume accounts don’t. Every charge is itemized before you sign, including how postage is billed, then shows on the order it belongs to.

To compare the two, take one quote from each on the same three months of orders and divide the monthly total by orders shipped. Our guide to reading a 3PL quote lists the lines to match up, and our 3PL cost calculator gives you a first estimate.

Support

Fulfyld puts a dedicated account manager on every brand and contrasts that with ticket queues. It lists phone and chat, and says the account manager handles migrations. If one person who knows your catalog is what you want, that’s a clear offer.

At Orderfy, every client gets direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the warehouse team handling their inventory, at any volume. Answers come with photos when photos help, and any order on hold shows the reason in Orderfy WMS. The question to ask either company is what happens when your contact is out: who answers, and what can they see about your order?

Which should you choose?

  • Pick Fulfyld if one all-inclusive rate matters more to you than seeing each charge, you want an SLA with automatic credits, or most of your customers are in the Southeast, close to Huntsville.
  • Pick Orderfy if you’re a Shopify brand at 1,000 to 10,000 orders a month that wants software your 3PL built, each charge on the order it belongs to, photos of every outgoing shipment, receiving within 24 hours and 24/7 access to the warehouse team, with Amazon FBA prep in the same building.
  • If you’re not sure, export three months of orders by destination and see how many ship within a day or two of each warehouse. Then ask each company for its SLA terms in a document you can read, and compare what each one pays out when it misses. Our SLA benchmarks guide lists what a 3PL SLA should cover.

Moving from Fulfyld to Orderfy

You sign the services agreement inside Orderfy WMS, and inbound shipments open once it’s signed and the opening deposit is paid. We set up your SKUs in Orderfy WMS and connect your Shopify store through our native app, then receive your inventory within 24 hours of delivery, count it against your packing list and photograph it. Stock levels update in Shopify once the count is in.

Fulfyld says its account manager handles migrations, so ask it how and when stock is released to a carrier for the trip to Texas. Our 30-day plan for switching 3PLs lays out the order of steps for avoiding a stockout, and if you import, we’ll quote the inbound freight too.

Frequently asked questions

Fulfyld says every order ships from one inventory pool in the Huntsville, Alabama metro, with headquarters at 511 6th St., Madison, AL. Its locations page says ground transit reaches most of the US in 1 to 3 days (checked November 17, 2026). Orderfy ships from one warehouse at 1824 N 1st St Ste 400, Garland, TX 75040, in the center of the US.

Fulfyld charges one flat per-order rate that it says is all-inclusive: pick, pack, same-day shipping, receiving and dock-to-stock, integrations and the account manager. It doesn’t publish dollar rates and says it sends quotes within one business day. Orderfy itemizes every charge before you sign, with pick and pack from $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders.

Fulfyld says it signs a formal SLA backed by financial credits that appear automatically on the next invoice, and it publishes 99.9% pick accuracy. The SLA terms aren’t posted on its site, so ask for the document before you sign. Orderfy tracks 99.9% order accuracy in Orderfy WMS, reships a wrong or incomplete order free and credits its fulfillment fee.

Fulfyld’s site mentions its 3PL fulfillment software, a 3PL ecommerce dashboard and automated API integration, but it doesn’t name the warehouse management system. Orderfy runs Orderfy WMS, proprietary software built in-house and included for every client.

Fulfyld says most brands are live within two weeks and that the account manager handles migrations. At Orderfy we plan the move with you, receive your inventory within 24 hours of delivery, count it against your packing list and photograph it. Stock levels update in Shopify once the count is in.

Sources

Checked November 17, 2026.

Comparing quotes from Fulfyld and Orderfy?

Send your monthly orders, SKU count, channels and where your customers are, and we’ll send an itemized quote you can put next to Fulfyld’s flat per-order rate, line by line.

Get a Quote Call: (469) 833-4101