A mis-ship is an order that leaves the warehouse with the wrong item, the wrong quantity, a missing item or the wrong label. Each one costs a reship, a return or write-off and support time, and at 5,000 orders a month, 99.5% order accuracy still means 25 mis-ships.
What counts as a mis-ship
A mis-ship is a warehouse error in what went into the box or onto the label:
- Wrong item or wrong variant, such as the wrong size or color
- Wrong quantity or a missing item
- An extra item shipped
- A label swap, where two orders go to each other's customers
Carrier loss, damage in transit and addresses the customer typed wrong are tracked separately. Keep them out of the count so order accuracy measures only warehouse errors.
What a mis-ship costs
A wrong item costs about $37.70 in cash in the worked example in our mis-shipped orders guide: a second pick and pack, a second label, packaging, a return label, return processing, a share of units that can't be resold and two support contacts. A missing item costs about $18.10, because nothing comes back. Each reship also raises your cost per order.
Example costs, not Orderfy rates, at 5,000 orders a month and a blended $30 cash cost per error:
| Order accuracy | Mis-ships a month | Cash cost a month | Cash cost a year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 99.0% | 50 | $1,500 | $18,000 |
| 99.5% | 25 | $750 | $9,000 |
| 99.9% | 5 | $150 | $1,800 |
Chargebacks and customers who never order again add to these figures and never show on an invoice.
Who pays for a mis-ship
The contract decides. A common 3PL guarantee covers the reship and sometimes credits the fulfillment fee on the bad order, while support time, chargebacks and lost customers stay with you. Some terms cover less: as of November 2026, Stord's warehouse terms exclude liability for any mis-shipment except as agreed in an applicable service level agreement.
Before you sign, request the order accuracy formula, the list of what counts as an error and a monthly list of error orders with the cause of each.
How we handle it at Orderfy
Every item is scanned at pick and checked at pack, which catches a wrong size or color before the box is sealed. If we ship an order wrong or incomplete, we reship it free and credit that order's fulfillment fee. Staff photograph every outgoing shipment, and the photos sit on the order in Orderfy WMS, our proprietary inventory software, with the carrier handoff time.
Frequently asked questions
A mis-shipped order left the warehouse with the wrong item, the wrong quantity, a missing item or the wrong label. A parcel the carrier lost or damaged is a carrier claim and counts separately.
DCL Logistics' June 2026 KPI guide puts the industry benchmark above 99%. At 5,000 orders a month, 99% still means 50 mis-ships, so request a rate that comes with its formula and a monthly list of error orders.
Only when the item is worth more than the return costs. With an example $7.50 return label, $3.00 processing and 1 in 5 returns unsellable, the break-even landed cost is about $13, and below that the customer should keep it.
Get a quote from Orderfy
Send your monthly order volume and what you ship, and we'll build an itemized quote.