Definition

Rate shopping is comparing the price of every eligible carrier and service for each package, then buying the cheapest label that still meets the delivery promise. A useful comparison prices the full label, including residential, delivery area and fuel surcharges, because the lowest base rate can carry the highest total.

How rate shopping works

For each order, shipping software takes the package's weight and dimensions, the origin and destination ZIP codes, and the delivery promise from checkout. It quotes every carrier and service your rules allow, drops any that can't meet the promise, and buys the cheapest remaining label.

The quote depends on accurate package data. Carriers bill on billable weight, so a label bought on a guessed box size can be adjusted later for dimensional weight.

Why the base rate misleads

Carriers add different surcharges, so compare totals. As of November 2026, UPS and FedEx add a residential surcharge to each home delivery ($6.50 for UPS Ground and $6.45 for FedEx Ground and Home Delivery at list), a delivery area surcharge on listed ZIP codes, and a weekly fuel percentage of 30.00% on ground for the week of November 16, 2026.

The USPS price list for Ground Advantage has no residential, delivery area or fuel line. USPS has filed for an 11% fuel surcharge from January 17, 2027, pending review by the Postal Regulatory Commission, so rerun your comparison once it takes effect.

Worked example

In this example, the lowest base rate produces the highest label total. Example rates, not Orderfy's or any carrier's, for a 1 lb home delivery to zone 5:

OptionBase rateSurchargesFuel at 30%Label total
Carrier A ground$6.10$3.50 residential$2.88$12.48
Carrier B ground$6.40$2.90 residential$2.79$12.09
Postal ground service$8.90NoneNone$8.90

If rate shopping moves 2,000 of 5,000 monthly orders from Carrier A to the postal service, the saving is $3.58 a label, or $7,160 a month.

What to check with a 3PL

  1. Which carriers and services it compares on each order, and which rules limit the choice.
  2. Whether the comparison includes surcharges and fuel, or only base rates.
  3. Who keeps the saving: postage billed at cost, with a markup, or from a rate card with the margin built in.
  4. Whether the label is bought on the packed weight and size.

The Shopify Shipping vs 3PL rates guide compares these postage billing models on a full month of orders.

Frequently asked questions

No. Carrier-calculated rates set what the customer pays at checkout, with carriers such as UPS or FedEx pricing the order details. Rate shopping happens after the order is placed, when the shipper picks which label to buy.

Not always. Contract rates differ by shipper, and USPS has no residential or delivery area line on Ground Advantage as of November 2026, which helps it on light home deliveries. Compare total label cost on your own shipments.

It can if the rules allow slower services. Set each rule by the transit time your checkout promises, so the software only compares services that meet it.

Get a quote from Orderfy

Send your monthly order volume and what you ship, and we'll build an itemized quote.

Get a quote Call: (469) 833-4101

Sources