Selery runs six warehouses, including two in Carrollton, Texas, on licensed ShipHero software and publishes per-order rates from $1.00 to $1.90+. Orderfy runs one Dallas–Fort Worth warehouse on Orderfy WMS, our proprietary software built in-house, with every charge shown on the order it belongs to.
We’re Orderfy, so we’re not neutral. The Selery details below come from Selery’s own website, checked on November 17, 2026, with links at the end. Prices and policies change, so confirm anything important with Selery directly.
Choose Selery if:
- You want stock in several US regions. Its locations page lists Carrollton, TX (two sites), Salt Lake City, Algonquin, IL, Orlando and Hickory, NC.
- You want published rates before a sales call. Per-order tiers, storage and added-item fees are on its pricing page.
- You want the highest published accuracy rate. Selery publishes 99.96% accuracy, plus a 90-day satisfaction guarantee.
Choose Orderfy if you’re a Shopify brand and want:
- Warehouse software your 3PL built. Orderfy WMS is proprietary, built in-house and included for every client.
- Every charge on the order it belongs to, billed weekly with autopay and itemized before you sign.
- Photos of every outgoing shipment on the order, with the carrier handoff time.
- One warehouse in the center of the US, with direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the warehouse team.
Orderfy vs Selery at a glance
| Orderfy | Selery | |
|---|---|---|
| Warehouses | Carrollton, TX (two sites), Salt Lake City, Algonquin, IL, Orlando and Hickory, NC, per its locations page | One warehouse in the center of the US (Dallas–Fort Worth) |
| Who it’s for | Businesses shipping 100 to 100,000 orders a month; fashion, health and beauty, subscription boxes, specialty goods, Amazon and Shopify sellers | Shopify brands shipping 1,000 to 10,000 orders a month, plus Amazon sellers. No volume minimum |
| Contract | “No, you can cancel at any time” | Services agreement signed inside Orderfy WMS |
| Pick and pack | Startup $1.90+, Growth $1.50+ or Scale $1.00+ per order, plus $0.25 per added item | Itemized quote. Pick and pack from $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders |
| Storage | $2 a bin or $25 a pallet a month | Receiving and storage in your itemized quote |
| Other fees | Returns, FBA prep, kitting, receiving and customer service by quote | Monthly account fee for smaller accounts, waived at high volume and listed on your quote |
| Billing | Not published | Weekly, with autopay. Each charge shows in Orderfy WMS on the order it belongs to |
| Warehouse software | ShipHero (“We use ShipHero”), licensed | Orderfy WMS, our proprietary software, built in-house and included |
| Shopify connection | Integrates with “almost every online shopping cart” | Native Shopify app. Orders reach us within minutes, stock syncs in real time and tracking posts when the label is created |
| Same-day shipping | Orders by 12pm (noon) CST ship the same day, Monday to Friday | Same-day shipping |
| Order accuracy | 99.96% published. On a mis-ship, Selery covers the return cost and waives pick, pack and shipping fees | 99.9%, tracked in Orderfy WMS. A wrong or incomplete order is reshipped free and its fulfillment fee credited |
| Support | An account manager for every partner, plus people who pick up the phone | Direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the warehouse team |
| Shipment photos | Not published | Every outgoing shipment, on the order with the carrier handoff time |
| Amazon FBA prep | Quoted; 8 to 72 hours published | Orderfy Prep for FBA-only, wholesale and arbitrage sellers, tracked in Orderfy WMS |
| Moving | “1000+ orders move for free” to Selery; 90-day guarantee that covers the cost of moving you to another provider | We plan the move with you. Inventory is received within 24 hours of delivery, counted and photographed |
Where Selery is stronger
- A multi-region footprint. Selery lists six warehouses: two in Carrollton, Texas, plus Salt Lake City, Algonquin, Illinois, Orlando and Hickory, North Carolina. If most of your customers sit in the Southeast or the Mountain West, stock closer to them shortens transit. You pay storage and receiving in each building you use. We keep one inventory in Dallas–Fort Worth.
- Published rates. Selery puts three per-order tiers, added-item fees and storage on its pricing page, so you can estimate a bill before a call. We quote from your numbers instead.
- A higher published accuracy rate. Selery publishes 99.96% accuracy. Ours is 99.9%, tracked in Orderfy WMS. Selery’s number is higher, and on a mis-ship it covers the return cost and waives the pick, pack and shipping fees.
- A guarantee and a free move in. Selery’s site says “1000+ orders move for free” when you change your 3PL, and a 90-day satisfaction guarantee: “we’ll cover the costs to move you to another provider”. Read both offers closely before you sign anywhere, ours included.
- An account manager and phone support. Selery says every partner gets their own account manager and that its people pick up the phone. Some brands want one named person. We route you to the team handling your inventory instead.
- A wider volume range. Selery says it supports businesses shipping 100 to 100,000 orders a month. Its Startup tier covers a brand that has just launched, and its Scale tier covers volume well above where we focus.
- Cancel at any time. Selery’s pricing page answers “No” to a long-term contract and says you can cancel at any time.
Where Orderfy is stronger
- Software built by your 3PL. Selery says “We use ShipHero”, a warehouse system ShipHero also licenses to other 3PLs. Orderfy WMS is our own proprietary software, built in-house and included for every client. When a Shopify brand kept some stock in its own building, we added a setting so Orderfy WMS takes only the orders Shopify routes to our location. The same team that runs the floor makes that kind of change.
- Bills you can check order by order. We bill weekly with autopay, and each charge shows in Orderfy WMS on the order it belongs to. A line you question traces back to one order. Selery doesn’t publish its billing schedule, and its returns, receiving, kitting and customer service fees are quoted.
- Proof of every shipment. Staff photograph every outgoing shipment, and the order page in Orderfy WMS shows “Handed to” with the carrier, the time and the photos. Deliveries are counted against your packing list and photographed on arrival. Selery doesn’t publish shipment photos.
- One inventory, one team. Your stock stays in one warehouse in the center of the US, handled by the same people every day. Ground shipping reaches both coasts quickly. You reorder against one count and you’re welcome to tour the building.
- A native Shopify app. Orders reach us within minutes, stock syncs to Shopify in real time and tracking posts as soon as the label is created. Selery says it integrates with “almost every online shopping cart”.
- Amazon FBA prep for FBA-only sellers. Selery lists FBA prep as a quoted service. Orderfy Prep works with FBA-only sellers, including wholesale and arbitrage, and tracks each shipment in Orderfy WMS.
Pricing
Selery publishes three tiers: Startup at “$1.90+ /order”, Growth at “$1.50+ /order” and Scale at “$1.00+ /order”. Added items cost “just $0.25 each”, storage is “a bin for $2 per month or a pallet for $25 per month”, and the page says you can “save 10% to 25% with ultra-low shipping rates”. Returns, FBA prep, kitting, receiving and customer service say “Ask for quote”.
The table below is arithmetic on those published rates, before postage, packaging and storage. The plus sign means “starting at”, so your quote can come in higher. Confirm which tier your volume lands in, because the rate changes the monthly total by thousands of dollars.
| Selery tier | One-item order | Three-item order | 5,000 one-item orders |
|---|---|---|---|
| Startup, $1.90+ | $1.90+ | $2.40+ | $9,500+ |
| Growth, $1.50+ | $1.50+ | $2.00+ | $7,500+ |
| Scale, $1.00+ | $1.00+ | $1.50+ | $5,000+ |
Orderfy quotes from your numbers: orders per month, items per order, storage, receiving and packaging. Pick and pack starts at $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders. Smaller accounts pay a monthly account fee that depends on volume and services, high-volume accounts don’t, and every charge is itemized before you sign, including how postage is billed.
Put both quotes next to three months of your real orders, with the same items per order and the same packaging. The lines Selery quotes by request (returns, receiving, kitting) are where the totals usually move apart. Our guide to reading a 3PL quote lists what to match line by line, and the hidden costs guide covers the fees that appear after signing.
Support
Selery assigns each partner an account manager and says its people “actually pick up the phone”. That works well when you want one contact who knows your account and calls you back.
At Orderfy, your team gets direct communication channels for 24/7 access to the people who received, packed or shipped your inventory, and any order on hold shows the reason in Orderfy WMS. Answers come with photos when they help. In the words of Alex Crealyte, an Orderfy client: “10/10 reliable fulfillment. Orderfy is an actual fulfillment partner unlike other 3pls. Great communication and always ships same day.”
Test either one before you sign. Send a question on a Friday afternoon and see who answers and how fast.
Which should you choose?
- Pick Selery if you need stock in more than one US region, want per-order tiers and storage rates published up front, value a 99.96% accuracy rate and a named account manager, or want the free move and guarantee on its site.
- Pick Orderfy if you’re a Shopify brand at 1,000 to 10,000 orders a month that wants software built by the 3PL, each charge on its order, photos of every outgoing shipment and 24/7 access to the warehouse team, with Amazon FBA prep in the same building.
- If you’re not sure, export three months of orders by destination and by items per order. A wide spread across the Southeast and the West favors several warehouses. Mostly one or two items per order and a billing process you want to audit favors a single building and an itemized bill.
Moving from Selery to Orderfy
We set up your SKUs in Orderfy WMS and connect your Shopify store through our app. You sign the services agreement inside Orderfy WMS, inbound shipments open once it’s signed and the opening deposit is paid, and we receive your inventory within 24 hours of delivery. Each delivery is counted against your packing list and photographed, and stock levels update in Shopify once it’s counted in.
Selery says you can cancel at any time, so a contract term shouldn’t hold you in place. Plan the move around your lowest-volume week, keep Selery shipping until Orderfy has counted your stock, and then switch your Shopify location. Our guide to switching 3PLs and the guide to moving Shopify inventory to a 3PL cover the steps in order.
Frequently asked questions
Both work at that size. Selery says it supports businesses shipping 100 to 100,000 orders a month, and Orderfy is built for Shopify brands shipping 1,000 to 10,000. Choose Orderfy for in-house software, every charge on its order and photos of every shipment. Choose Selery for several US warehouses or published per-order tiers.
Selery lists two sites in Carrollton, Texas, in the Dallas area, plus Salt Lake City, Algonquin, Orlando and Hickory. Orderfy’s one warehouse is at 1824 N 1st St Ste 400, Garland, TX 75040, in Dallas–Fort Worth, and you’re welcome to tour it.
Selery’s pricing page says “We use ShipHero”, a warehouse system that ShipHero also licenses to other 3PLs. Orderfy runs Orderfy WMS, our proprietary software, built in-house and included for every client.
No. Selery’s pricing page answers “No, you can cancel at any time”. It also offers a 90-day satisfaction guarantee under which it says it will cover the costs to move you to another provider, so confirm the terms with Selery.
Selery lists $1.90+ on Startup, $1.50+ on Growth and $1.00+ on Scale, plus $0.25 for each added item. Storage is $2 a bin or $25 a pallet a month, and returns, FBA prep, kitting and receiving are quoted. Orderfy pick and pack starts at $1.00 per order for high-volume, single-item orders, with every charge itemized before you sign.
Sources
Checked November 17, 2026.
Comparing quotes from Selery and Orderfy?
Send your monthly orders, items per order, SKU count and where your customers are, and we’ll send an itemized quote you can put next to Selery’s rate card, line by line.